Well, if some country took you into detention, held you without charge or access to legal services, beat the living shit out of you every day—do you think that might make you less than charitable towards that country?

That’s the problem with Gitmo (and the black sites)—it does nothing to discourage terrorists, provides excellent recruitment material, and creates terrorists out of detainees.

Agreed. The problem we have now is--when dude from gitmo comes back and bombs us, Obama’s going to get blamed for what Bush done.